 Senior Member ◆◆◆◆ Posts: 4,980 Joined: Jul 1999 From: Norwich, UK |
#65▸ Posted: 25 Aug 1999, 11:05 GMT
A culture-hero motif can be old without being a fossilised newspaper. Repetition over generations selects for what a community needs the story to keep doing. The teacher from waters may persist because it solves a social problem: civilisation must arrive from beyond ordinary village memory, but still be kin enough to teach.
long machinery, small claims |
Anonymous Coward  (unregistered) User ID: 63706085 From: a VPN, probably |
#66▸ Posted: 06 Sep 1999, 17:29 GMT
This thread is making the alien version feel cheap, which is annoying because I liked the alien version.
|
 New Member ◆ Posts: 31 Joined: Jan 2002 From: Glasgow, UK |
#67▸ Posted: 10 Sep 1999, 20:17 GMT
Same. But the cheap version was also easier because it answered everything with one answer. The real version keeps opening more drawers.
trying to learn before arguing |
 Resident Skeptic ◆◆◆◆◆ Posts: 16,720 Joined: Apr 1998 From: Chicago, US |
#68▸ Posted: 10 Sep 1999, 15:01 CST
That is how you know you are moving from lore to inquiry. One answer becomes ten better questions and everybody gets less comfortable.
I believe exactly one thread on this board. Guess which. -- the 5% |
Anonymous Coward  (unregistered) User ID: 51988159 From: a VPN, probably |
#69▸ Posted: 22 Sep 1999, 13:12 PST
Where does Enki fit in this? Sitchin makes him the genetic engineer good guy.
|
 Senior Member ◆◆◆◆ Posts: 4,890 Joined: Jun 1999 From: Leeds, UK |
#70▸ Posted: 22 Sep 1999, 22:10 GMT
Enki/Ea is a major god of wisdom, fresh water, craft, mischief, creation and survival, depending on text and period. In Atrahasis he helps create humans and later warns the flood hero. That is rich theology. Sitchin flattens him into a sympathetic lab director because the modern plot needs one.
Leeds · the tablets say less than the documentaries claim |
 Member ◆◆◆ Posts: 612 Joined: Sep 2001 From: Durham, UK |
#71▸ Posted: 26 Sep 1999, 08:50 GMT
Enki matters because he lives at boundaries: freshwater under the earth, craft under order, trickery under wisdom, mercy under decree. He is not less strange when he stops being a geneticist. He becomes more anciently strange, which is better.
the source, then the speculation |
Anonymous Coward  (unregistered) User ID: 22918813 From: a VPN, probably |
#72▸ Posted: 05 Oct 1999, 07:24 GMT
Can someone post the actual King List numbers? People keep referring to them like everyone has them memorised.
|