 Moderator · Asia Desk ◆◆◆◆◆ Posts: 14,002 Joined: Sep 1999 From: Yokohama, JP |
#41▸ Posted: 28 Apr 1999, 10:00 JST
[staff] The thread remains open, but the unresolved point is now narrow.
Claims about contact heredity require primary material: the plate, a verified reproduction, excavation context, or biological data tied to the site. Until then, please keep new replies focused on sources rather than expanding the theory.
Moderator · Yokohama |
 Senior Member ◆◆◆◆ Posts: 4,980 Joined: Jul 1999 From: Norwich, UK |
#42▸ Posted: 11 May 1999, 10:22 JST
The culture-to-selection path is still interesting. A repeated contact practice could bias diet, status, marriage, teaching, or childhood survival, and those pressures can matter over time.
But that is a pathway to investigate, not proof of heredity. It needs local evidence, not just an elegant bridge between myth and biology.
the long machinery |
 Member ◆◆◆ Posts: 612 Joined: Sep 2001 From: Durham, UK |
#43▸ Posted: 24 May 1999, 10:41 JST
I will concede the title overstated the result. Contact heredity sounds cleaner than the evidence allows.
What survives, to me, is contact pressure: an outside group or tradition altering institutions enough that reproduction, teaching, and memory changed downstream. That is weaker than my opening claim, but not empty.
the door opened from outside |
 Senior Member ◆◆◆◆ Posts: 4,890 Joined: Jun 1999 From: Leeds, UK |
#44▸ Posted: 07 Jun 1999, 11:05 JST
Myth can function as a map here, not a verdict. The repeated teacher pattern tells us where ancient communities placed anxiety about knowledge, descent, and authority.
It does not tell us which event happened until the text, object, and site context line up.
method, not machines |
 Moderator · Asia Desk ◆◆◆◆◆ Posts: 14,002 Joined: Sep 1999 From: Yokohama, JP |
#45▸ Posted: 20 Jun 1999, 11:30 JST
[staff] Marking thread unresolved pending primary material.
The narrowed claim is now culture-to-selection pressure after possible contact, not demonstrated biological intervention. Bring the plate, verified reproduction, excavation context, or biological data before expanding it again.
Moderator · Yokohama |