Anonymous Coward  (unregistered) User ID: 99953843 From: a VPN, probably |
#17▸ Posted: 26 Feb 1999, 19:22 GMT
So what is the best English book for someone who wants the real version without learning cuneiform?
|
 Senior Member ◆◆◆◆ Posts: 4,890 Joined: Jun 1999 From: Leeds, UK |
#18▸ Posted: 26 Feb 1999, 20:05 GMT
Start with Stephanie Dalley for myths in translation, Kramer with caution because he is older but still useful, and anything with notes that tell you where the broken places are. A translation that admits uncertainty is usually more trustworthy than one that never blushes.
Leeds · the tablets say less than the documentaries claim |
 New Member ◆ Posts: 31 Joined: Jan 2002 From: Glasgow, UK |
#19▸ Posted: 02 Mar 1999, 18:12 GMT
Ordered Dalley from the library. This board is going to make me poorer and less certain.
trying to learn before arguing |
 Resident Skeptic ◆◆◆◆◆ Posts: 16,720 Joined: Apr 1998 From: Chicago, US |
#20▸ Posted: 02 Mar 1999, 12:31 CST
Less certain is cheaper than wrong certainty, even with postage.
I believe exactly one thread on this board. Guess which. -- the 5% |
Anonymous Coward  (unregistered) User ID: 75561560 From: a VPN, probably |
#21▸ Posted: 10 Mar 1999, 09:08 PST
Nibiru has a 3,600 year orbit. That matches the sar or shar, does it not?
|
 Senior Member ◆◆◆◆ Posts: 4,890 Joined: Jun 1999 From: Leeds, UK |
#22▸ Posted: 10 Mar 1999, 18:33 GMT
It matches a number after Sitchin decides it should. A sar can be 3,600 in the sexagesimal system, but that does not make every use of the number an orbital period. If a culture has a unit equal to 3,600, you still have to prove the text is counting years, then prove it is counting an orbit, then identify the body. Sitchin treats the first step as the whole staircase.
Leeds · the tablets say less than the documentaries claim |
 Member ◆◆ Posts: 640 Joined: Oct 2000 From: New York, US |
#23▸ Posted: 15 Mar 1999, 13:02 EST
Base-60 is a machine for making large clean numbers. That is exactly why later number-mystics love it. The danger is mistaking a flexible measuring system for a message addressed to us.
count the misses too |
 Moderator · Asia Desk ◆◆◆◆◆ Posts: 14,002 Joined: Sep 1999 From: Yokohama, JP |
#24▸ Posted: 19 Mar 1999, 08:34 JST
Material note: "abrupt sophistication" is partly an archive problem. Wet mud preserves tablets; wood, fibre, baskets, spoken law and practice do not preserve the same way. Southern Iraq did not become clever only when it became legible to us.
moderator when needed, geologist by training |