 New Member ◆ Posts: 29 Joined: Oct 1999 From: New Jersey, US |
#1▸ Posted: 20 Dec 1995, 09:12 PST
Right, I'm saying it: a hot dog is a sandwich. The USDA agrees with me. It's meat between bread. That's the definition. Brace yourselves, the replies are coming.
-- the brave truth-teller |
 Senior Member ◆◆◆◆ Posts: 11,200 Joined: Jun 1999 From: Seattle, US |
#2▸ Posted: 20 Dec 1995, 20:30 PST
WRONG. A sandwich has TWO SEPARATE PIECES OF BREAD. A hot dog bun is ONE piece, hinged. This is not a sandwich. This is a hot dog. We have a word for it already.
|
 Member ◆◆◆ Posts: 8,120 Joined: Nov 1999 From: Leeds, UK |
#3▸ Posted: 21 Dec 1995, 07:48 PST
Okay but hear me out -- if we're defining sandwich by bread topology, then we have to ask what counts as "separate pieces" and what constitutes "enclosure." A submarine sandwich has one continuous hinge too. Are we sure we have a consistent rule here?
I'm genuinely fascinated by where the line is.
taxonomy rules! |
 New Member ◆ Posts: 29 Joined: Oct 1999 From: New Jersey, US |
#4▸ Posted: 21 Dec 1995, 19:06 PST
THANK YOU, Nia. Exactly. It's all about the structural containment of the filling. Hot dog, sandwich, submarine -- same principle.
-- vindicated |
Anonymous Coward  (unregistered) User ID: 71433346 From: a VPN, probably |
#5▸ Posted: 22 Dec 1995, 06:24 PST
A HOT DOG IS A TACO.
|
 Senior Member ◆◆◆◆ Posts: 11,200 Joined: Jun 1999 From: Seattle, US |
#6▸ Posted: 22 Dec 1995, 17:42 PST
Oh great, now we're doing this. No. A taco doesn't have a hinge. A taco folds. Good grief.
|
 Moderator ◆◆◆◆◆ Posts: 11,455 Joined: Jan 2000 From: Cork, IE |
#7▸ Posted: 23 Dec 1995, 05:00 PST
I'm about two more posts away from locking this in the name of peace and holiday cheer. That said, this is the dumbest thing I've read all week and I'm genuinely enjoying it. Carry on, but play nice.
-- keeper of order |
 Member ◆◆ Posts: 38 Joined: Sep 1998 From: Norfolk, UK |
#8▸ Posted: 23 Dec 1995, 16:18 PST
You lot are all mad. In my day we just bought the hot dog, ate the hot dog, and didn't spend three hours arguing about what to call it. Though I do love you all for trying.
-- baking since 1952 |