 Member ◆◆ Posts: 61 Joined: Jul 1996 From: Peru |
#9▸ Posted: 13 Aug 1995, 12:24 MST
The reason the myth sticks is that people see the finished structure and their brain rebels. It LOOKS impossible because they're imagining it done quickly or with ease. Leedskalnin spent decades doing this alone. That's not a miracle -- that's a man who decided he would move mountains (or at least coral) and did the work required.
|
 Member ◆◆ Posts: 640 Joined: Oct 2000 From: New York, US |
#10▸ Posted: 15 Aug 1995, 12:48 MST
I'll grant you the point on the mechanical advantage side. I still think Leedskalnin claimed something more, but I can see how the tripod and wedge system would handle the loads. And I suppose if you're working alone and have 28 years, the timeline supports it. I'm not fully convinced the anti-gravity angle is nonsense, but the lever explanation is more parsimonious than I initially thought.
|
 Member ◆◆ Posts: 66 Joined: Dec 1997 From: Germany |
#11▸ Posted: 17 Aug 1995, 13:12 MST
What's interesting to me is how the myth reveals what we want to believe about genius. An eccentric man, working alone, using patience and an understanding of physics that was already ancient -- that's not dramatic enough. We want secret knowledge, lost sciences, forbidden understanding. The real story, though, shows something just as impressive: obsessive dedication and the willingness to do unglamorous work for decades. Leedskalnin didn't need to be magical. He just needed to be stubborn.
|
 Member ◆◆◆ Posts: 176 Joined: Feb 1996 From: Norway |
#12▸ Posted: 19 Aug 1995, 13:36 MST
And that's the throughline worth following. We can reconstruct his methods from the photographs and the remaining equipment. The work is slow, methodical, and entirely within the bounds of physics as understood in the 1920s. Not every remarkable human achievement needs to violate the laws of nature. Sometimes a man and a lever are enough.
|
 Member ◆◆◆ Posts: 612 Joined: Sep 2001 From: Durham, UK |
#13▸ Posted: 21 Aug 1995, 14:01 MST
I think we've reached the center of this. Coral Castle remains an extraordinary accomplishment -- not because the physics is mysterious, but because one man with patience and leverage built a structure that has lasted nearly a century. The real secret wasn't hidden knowledge or anti-gravity. It was discipline, obsession, and understanding how to move stone. That's impressive enough.
|